So I like using pets ANYONE can find easily and level easily so this is what I used.
Carrotus Maximus: Any frog with Frog Kiss followed by cleansing rain when frog form is active *repeatedly* (third shot should be water jet just in case cleansing rain hasn't had time for cooldown, water jet has a boost against this guy too). Do this till he dies before swapping.
In second position any Strider or Dancing Water Skimmer with Pump and Cleansing Rain, same concept pump cleansing rain, pump cleansing rain, etc.
I didn't need my third pet but I used Emperor Crab with Whirlpool, Renewing Mist, and Surge. All strong against this guy and easy pets to get and worked great!
Gnawface: Start with any fox with Howl and Dazzling Dance, cast Dazzling Dance, you may have time for one cast of Bite but if your health is below 500 jump right to Howl (make sure howl is cast right before death!). Cast Howl and fox should die next hit.
In second position I used Kun-Lai-Runt, cast Rampage. That should be the end of the fight. Third pet doesn't matter.
Gorefu: Use any moth, or three of them. Defeated this guy with, not even kidding, 1 Oasis Moth and he still had half his health when the battle was over. Start with Moth Dust, followed by Cocoon Strike, then while those cool down hit with Alpha Strike. Repeat. Easy as pie.
Quest
Pets Versus Pests
Quest facts and objectives from the current retail game data.
The highest voted Wowhead comments for this page. They are community notes, not TheWoWDB comments.
As of Live:
To unlock this quest, you must be lvl 100, as well as have your garrison upgraded to lvl 3. Hope this helps.
Forget everything and just use Pandaren Water Spirit and Chrominius (and a third pet can be whatever)
1. Pandaren Water Spirit : Geyser -> Whirlpool -> Swap pet
2. Chrominius : Howl -> Surge of Power
3. Whatever is left of your oponnent, do it.Worked on every enemy. Only had to heal my pets once.
Quest facts
The client quest POI data records no map location for this quest, so no map is shown.
Check whether you have already completed this quest
in-game: /run print(C_QuestLog.IsQuestFlaggedCompleted(36423))
Description
I've been trying to get this place ready for your pets, but we've uncovered some rude pests while building the garrison. I tried to take care of them myself, but they are too tough for my meager team. There's an angry carrot in the garden, an enormous rat eating our food rations, and an ornery water creature harassing the fishermen. If you can take care of them, I'll be free to finish up my work on your menagerie.
Community notes from Wowhead · 110 comments
Top 3 shown aboveThe comments below were written by Wowhead users. They are community notes, not TheWoWDB comments. See them in context on Wowhead.
The top 3 are shown in Top Comments above. Read all 110 on Wowhead.
Spell: Garrison: Pet Menagerie