This item is acquired in-game. See its sources below.
Encounters that drop this item, from the game's own dungeon journal. Drop chances are not stored in the client data we mine, so none are shown here. The tags show which difficulties each encounter can award it on.
Cookie's Tenderizer is not traded on the Auction House, so it has no live market price. Its first-party game data (identity, effects and sources) is read from the official World of Warcraft client build.
In the Appearances collection, Cookie's Tenderizer is listed as Boss Drop. Appearance ID: 1183. 1 other item wears the same appearance:
Read from the World of Warcraft client build files.
In their in-game specialization descriptions, these specs name maces among their preferred weapons:
The 9 items nearest to Cookie's Tenderizer (item level 12) in item level among Weapon > Mace, from item level 14 to 22.
| Item | Item Level | Requires Level | Stats | Lowest Listed Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cookie's Tenderizer (this item) | 12 | 7 | 1.7 DPS, +2 Strength, +2 Stamina, +2 Critical Strike, +1 Versatility. Boss Drop | Not listed |
 Bronze Mace | 14 | 8 | 2.1 DPS, +2 Strength, +5 Critical Strike, +3 Stamina. Crafted with Classic Blacksmithing | 11 gold on 61 realms |
| Heavy Bronze Mace | 16 | 10 | 2.5 DPS, +4 Strength. Crafted with Classic Blacksmithing | 40 gold on 57 realms |
 Looming Gavel | 19 | 12 | 3.1 DPS, +5 Stamina, +2 Agility. World Drop | 283 gold on 56 realms |
 Sequoia Hammer | 19 | 12 | 3.1 DPS, +3 Intellect, +4 Stamina. World Drop | 10 gold on 53 realms |
 Midnight Mace | 21 | 14 | 3.5 DPS, +7 Shadow Resistance, +7 Agility. World Drop | 300 gold on 54 realms |
 Deadwood Sledge | 21 | 14 | 3.5 DPS, +3 Strength, +1 Stamina, +7 Versatility. World Drop | 776 gold on 51 realms |
| Giant Club | 21 | 14 | 3.5 DPS, +3 Strength, +5 Stamina. World Drop | 10 gold on 50 realms |
 Excavator's Brand | 22 | 15 | 3.5 DPS. World Drop | 499 gold on 64 realms |
 Murphstar | 22 | 14 | 3.5 DPS, +3 Intellect, +5 Stamina. World Drop | 1 gold on 51 realms |
Murphstar has the highest item level here (22). The lowest listed price among them is Murphstar at 1 gold in the US Auction House.
Next item levels up from Cookie's Tenderizer among Weapon > Mace: Goblin Nutcracker (item level 23), Mug O' Hurt (item level 24), Big Black Mace (item level 24), Skullcrusher Mace (item level 25) and Diamond-Tip Bludgeon (item level 25).
Nearest lower item levels below Cookie's Tenderizer among Weapon > Mace: Jiro Tuning Hammer (item level 1), Mace of Renewed Purpose (item level 1), Gavel of Lost Purpose (item level 1), Lost Sunset Scepter (item level 1) and Umbralwarden's Soul Gavel (item level 1).
Built from the World of Warcraft client build files and recorded Auction House snapshots.
Cookie's Tenderizer is in the Classic Era game data, the era World of Warcraft: Forever is built on. Blizzard describes Forever as vanilla World of Warcraft plussed up: its story sits in year one, characters level to 60 and stay there, and it launches November 4, 2026. Blizzard has not said which vanilla items appear in Forever, so nothing here is a Forever claim; it is the Classic Era record for Cookie's Tenderizer next to the live retail market on this page.
Read next: World of Warcraft: Forever is Classic+, launching November 4 · Forever's class revamps and new race and class combinations · Classic Era page for Cookie's Tenderizer
TheWoWDB