Cloak of the Unseen Path

This quest is available to hunters only and awards the cloak piece of the Trappings of the Unseen Path.

Trappings of the Unseen Path

• 
  
• Honored: Ring - Signet of the Unseen Path (quest)
• 
  
• Revered: Cloak - Cloak of the Unseen Path (quest)
• 
  
• Exalted: Weapon - Scythe of the Unseen Path (quest)
• 
  

This quest requires the Qiraji Spiked Hilt, which can drop from any of the bosses in the Ruins of Ahn'Qiraj, as well as idols and scarabs which can either drop off trash or can be found inside Scarab Coffers.

Even though it is obtainable at any reputation level, players must reach Revered with the Cenarion Circle before being able to complete this quest.

I can confirm that this, and the other 2 quests for the Trapping of the Unseen Path count towards the Loremaster of Kalimdor achievement and grant 500 Reputation.

If you have all the items and rep, and head toward the question mark to turn them in (for example, if you're not coming from inside the raid because some of the items were in your bank for a loooooong time), that would guide you to Cenarion Hold, but you won't find Keyl there. He was moved to the raid entrance, but the question mark was never changed. Ignore the faulty minimap directions, fly south to raid entrance, turn in quest.