The Toymaster

Going for this achievement can be a pain if you are like me and destroyed many of your toys because of bag space being an issue. With that said, I pointed out some "easy to find/get" toys to help you get the achievements quicker. As I find more “easy to find toys,” I will update this post.

First stop is Toy Vendors

[npc=52809] - This goblin walks up and down The Drag in Orgrimmar pushing a cart. He sells 7 toys in total (Horde)

[item=54437] 10 gold
[item=54438] 10 gold
[item=104323] 40 gold
[item=104324] 40 gold
[item=54343] 40 gold
[item=44606] 250 gold
[item=45057] 250 gold
[item=69895] 10 silver, only available during Children's Week

[npc=52358] - This gnome walks around The Trade District in Stormwind City pushing a cart. He sells 7 toys in total too (Alliance)

[item=54437] 10 gold
[item=54438] 10 gold
[item=104323] 40 gold
[item=104324] 40 gold
[item=54343] 40 gold
[item=44606] 250 gold
[item=45057] 250 gold
[item=69895] 10 silver, only available during Children's Week

[npc=29478] - This gnome stands in his toy shop in Sunreaver’s Square in Dalaran. He sells the same seven toys as the Horde and Alliance vendors (Both)

*note* If you are exalted with the faction you are buying from or have any racials, you may get a discount from the prices listed above

Next stop is The Valley of the Four Winds

[item=88801] sold by [npc=64395] for 40 [currency=402]. He is located Halfhill in Valley of the Four Winds. Most get their Ironpaw tokens from doing the daily quests in this zone, but a quicker way of doing this is surely the way to go. There is a repeatable quest called Replenishing the Pantry that awards you with 1 Ironpaw token and a small amount of gold. You buy empty containers from [npc=64940] in Halfhill for 1 gold 50 silver. You turn these into a[item=87557] by adding various meats, fish, or vegetables. On most servers Raw Turtle Meat, Raw Tiger Steak, and Mushan Ribs are the most affordable, and you only need 20 of them. Sometimes you can find cheap fish, but stay away from Golden Carp because you have to turn in 60 of them. After you have filled your bags by right clicking them, go back to Nam Ironpaw to complete the quest. Do this 40 times and you’ll enjoy flipping tables!

While you are in Halfhill, you can pick up:

[item=90175] and [item=89869] sold by [npc=58706] for 200 gold each. I thought there used to be a discount for being best friends with her, but I do not appear to be getting that discount as of 6.0.3.

Head over to Nesingwary’s Safari which is in the southwest part of The Valley of Four Winds

[item=88802] and [item=91904] are sold by [npc=55143] for 1,000 gold each. A bit pricey, but two more closer to the achievement!

Darkmoon Island is the place to go!

Darkmoon Island while Darkmoon Faire is in town will provide some toys. It's not just about heirlooms, transmogs, and companions anymore. There are a few toys that are easily obtained. You can either grind out the daily quests for [currency=515], or be lazy like me and buy Banner of the Fallen, Monstrous Egg, Fallen Adventurer's Journal, Ornate Weapon, Captured Insignia, Mysterious Grimoire, A Treatise on Strategy, Imbued Crystal, and Soothsayer's Runes that allows you to get 80 Darkmoon Prize Tickets once the quests are turned in. Do this on two separate characters that are 85+, added with a few dailies and you will have enough currency for:

[item=116139] sold by [npc=85484] for 90 [currency=515]
[item=90899] sold by [npc=14828] for 90 [currency=515]

You can also buy [item=75042] from Carl Goodup for 10 silver assuming you do not have any discounts. He pushes a cart up and down the lower path of Darkmoon Island as far as just before the fishing dock (*thank you lilsniff for this information to be added*)

[item=116115] is awarded by completing the achievement Brood of Alysrazor. You have to fly through 50 rings in one session of flying. Ziggie Sparks will let you fly for the price of 1 Darkmoon Game Token

*note* If you chose to do the dailies, you have a small chance to get the Darkmoon Whistle from [item=93724] that is awarded for the dailies.

Something to be aware of -

I got lucky and had several [currency=391]’s and [currency=241]’s that I didn’t even know about. Hopefully you will have the same luck because there are more toys to be had!

Tol Barad here we come!

[item=63141] is sold by [npc=48531] in Tol Barad Peninsula for 40 [currency=391] (Horde)
[item=63141] is sold by [npc=47328] in Tol Barad Peninsula for 40 [currency=391] (Alliance)

If you do not have any of these commendations, don't worry. Assuming your faction has control over Tol Barad, you have 12 daily quests that can be completed here. This is not including the Victory in Tol Barad. Either way, you should only have to knock out 4 days of dailies to get this toy.

Icecrown is just ahead!

Horde

All NPC’s can be found at the Argent Tournament Grounds in Icecrown

[item=45014] is sold by [npc=33553] for 15 [currency=241]
[item=45016] is sold by [npc=33555] for 15 [currency=241]
[item=45015] is sold by [npc=33554] for 15 [currency=241]
[item=45013] is sold by [npc=33556] for 15 [currency=241]
[item=45017] is sold by [npc=33557] for 15 [currency=241]

Alliance

[item=45020] is sold by [npc=33657] for 15 [currency=241]
[item=45021] is sold by [npc=33653] for 15 [currency=241]
[item=45018] is sold by [npc=33310] for 15 [currency=241]
[item=45011] is sold by [npc=33307] for 15 [currency=241]
[item=45019] is sold by [npc=33650] for 15 [currency=241]

Both

[item=46843] is sold by [npc=34885] for 15 [currency=241]

If you do not have any Champion Seal’s, this will be a loooong – boring – exhausting grind of endless dailies.

If you happen to be among the lucky ones, or not, stop by The Storm Peaks, which isn’t too far away. There you will find Ancient Relics (Horde) or Ancient Relics (Alliance). Complete this quest, and the NPC's will then sell:

[item=43499], which is sold by [npc=30472] (Horde) for 10 [item=42780]
[item=43499], which is sold by [npc=29744] (Alliance) for 10 [item=42780]

Like stated previous, in order for these NPC’s to sell this toy, you need to complete the quest Ancient Relics first. This means you will need 20 [item=42780], which can be bought on the auction house (usually cheap), or by killing various mobs all around The Storm Peaks or [zone=4272].

Toys are account-bound; if you have any characters with [skill=202] you can make:

[item=17716]
[item=40895] (gnomish only)
[item=18660] (gnomish only)
[item=109183] - when WoD comes out
[item=23767] - even though engineers can make this, you do not have to have engineering to get this toy. On most servers, this will sell for 100-200 gold - give or take.

Two small closing notes:

1. World Events offer many toys. Some to keep your eye on, but not limited to:

Love is in the air
Lunar Festival
Children's Week
Brewfest
Hallow's End
Feast for Winter Veil

2. An easy way to help speed up this achievement is by using the filters in your toy box. There are options like “vendor," “quest,” “world event,” etc.. You can scroll over the toy and see some information such as “drop,” “zone,” “cost,” “vendor,” “achievement,” “category,” “location,” and “price.” This should speed up the process. Good luck

Updated to 6.2.0 - table now resembles your ingame toy box again.

• 
  
• Toys gained by Trading Card Game (TCG) / Promotion are crossed out
• 
  
• Contrary to the description, you need only 149 toys. The achievement's award will be the 150th, fullfilling its own requirement. Talking about paradoxes ;-)
• 
  

Toy Box Page 01 / 14

[item=64881]

[item=36862]

[item=86589]

[item=112324]

Pineapple Lounge Cushion

[item=69215]

[item=33223]

[item=115468]

[item=64456]

[item=79769]

[item=54212]

[item=45057]

[item=45020]

[item=46843]

[item=45021]

[item=45013]

[item=45018]

[item=45019]

Toy Box Page 02 / 14

[item=45014]

[item=45015]

[item=45017]

[item=45011]

[item=45016]

[item=119144]

[item=122120]

[item=114227]

[item=119432]

[item=33927]

[item=71137]

Burning Blade

[item=38301]

[item=116757]

[item=108743]

[item=50471]

[item=80822]

[item=127766]

Toy Box Page 03 / 14

[item=38578]

[item=122122]

[item=90899]

[item=122123]

[item=122121]

[item=88589]

[item=43499]

[item=21540]

[item=104309]

[item=122304]

[item=87528]

[item=119145]

[item=67097]

[item=116758]

[item=90883]

[item=104323]

[item=123851]

[item=90067]

Toy Box Page 04 / 14

[item=119083]

[item=88802]

[item=90888]

[item=104324]

[item=118937]

[item=119001]

[item=118222]

Spirit Wand

[item=69896]

[item=75042]

[item=116435]

[item=111476]

[item=128462]

[item=98132]

[item=63269]

[item=90175]

[item=95589]

[item=95590]

Toy Box Page 05 / 14

[item=113096]

[item=40895]

[item=88417]

[item=118716]

[item=69895]

[item=86568]

[item=119210]

[item=69777]

[item=122126]

[item=88385]

[item=86593]

[item=118244]

[item=127659]

[item=113631]

[item=127668]

Pretty Draenor Pearl

[item=64651]

[item=88579]

Toy Box Page 06 / 14

[item=68806]

[item=86571]

[item=69227]

[item=64373]

[item=86575]

[item=88580]

[item=33219]

[item=120276]

[item=119160]

[item=70722]

[item=116125]

Fuzzy Green Lounge Cushion

[item=64646]

[item=34686]

[item=23767]

[item=88566]

[item=108735]

[item=35275]

Toy Box Page 07 / 14

[item=117573]

[item=88531]

[item=119003]

[item=71259]

[item=119039]

[item=116115]

[item=115503]

[item=127696]

[item=72159]

[item=118938]

[item=116440]

[item=103685]

[item=119421]

[item=122187]

[item=46709]

[item=101571]

[item=105898]

[item=119092]

Toy Box Page 08 / 14

Muradin's Favor

[item=113670]

[item=70159]

[item=86596]

[item=46780]

[item=90427]

[item=89869]

[item=86586]

[item=86588]

[item=34499]

[item=108745]

[item=127864]

[item=122129]

[item=127666]

[item=32566]

[item=34480]

[item=13379]

[item=70161]

Toy Box Page 09 / 14

[item=88370]

[item=116651]

[item=64482]

[item=104294]

[item=117569]

[item=116067]

[item=119215]

[item=82467]

[item=88377]

[item=113375]

[item=122674]

[item=71628]

Safari Lounge Cushion

[item=119134]

[item=72161]

[item=45063]

[item=127859]

[item=128471]

Toy Box Page 10 / 14

[item=98136]

[item=17716]

[item=127394]

[item=116122]

[item=116456]

[item=119178]

[item=104302]

[item=119163]

[item=119182]

[item=64358]

[item=126931]

[item=64481]

[item=104262]

[item=88387]

[item=119212]

[item=119217]

[item=119218]

[item=119219]

Toy Box Page 11 / 14

Autographed Hearthstone Card

[item=88381]

[item=128328]

[item=44606]

[item=116139]

[item=66888]

[item=91904]

[item=64361]

[item=118221]

[item=109739]

[item=104318]

[item=54343]

[item=37710]

[item=116763]

[item=30690]

[item=63141]

[item=64997]

[item=37254]

Toy Box Page 12 / 14

Sylvanas' Music Box

[item=116856]

[item=116889]

[item=116888]

[item=116890]

[item=116891]

[item=127652]

[item=44430]

[item=88584]

[item=122700]

[item=122293]

[item=69775]

Orb of Deception

[item=88801]

[item=89999]

[item=122119]

[item=90000]

[item=49703]

Toy Box Page 13 / 14

Unusual Compass

Indestructible Bone

[item=69776]

[item=113570]

[item=53057]

[item=127670]

[item=116400]

[item=104331]

[item=86581]

[item=109183]

[item=18660]

[item=32542]

[item=44719]

[item=64383]

[item=17712]

[item=54438]

[item=54437]

[item=89222]

Toy Box Page 14 / 14

[item=35227]

[item=117550]

[item=36863]

[item=32782]

Zhevra Lounge Cushion

Main city banners sold in Argent Tournament Ground are counted as 2 toys each. If you add Orgrimmar banner to your box you'll get Stormwind one immediately, Silvermoon banner will add Exodar one, etc.