A Pirate Predicament

November 13th | Chapter 3 Part 1 of I Saved the Party and All I Got Were These Lousy Hats - The Case of the Superstitious and Hungry Pirates (no guide on Wowhead yet, but a guide on Warcraft Wiki can be found here):

• 
  
• Start the quest A Pirate Predicament at Alyx, telling you to check with the pirates north of the celebration area, near the shore./way #71 60.89 44.87 Pirate Camp
• 
  
• Get the next quest Pirate Foods and Superstitions and travel to the Booty Bay in Cape of Stranglethorn to talk to Kelsey Yance./way #210 42.81 68.97 Kelsey Yance
• 
  
• Go to the bunk area to find [item=229968]./way #210 42.88 72.83 Cooktholomew's belongings
• 
  
• Turn in the quest Pirate Foods and Superstitions at Scowling Rosa, this will complete part 1 of chapter 3, although you won't see notification of this on your screen./way #210 42 69 /tar Scowling Rosa as she's walking around
• 
  

If you thought that warbands means you can pick up this quest on any alt, you were wrong.
While I could do Chapter 2 on a different toon than Chapter 1 and mix it up wihout any problems, Alyx wasn't offering the pirates questline. There seems to be a hidden requirement - the alt that did Chapter 2 can pick this up, but she was already lvl 80 and I also wanted xp, since I was doing these quests anyway. On a new alt I had to do the whoooole thing again, from the start. It knows I did it already (Your warband has completed this quest) but won't let you pick up just what you're missing. Why would it make your life easier? Why would a video game be less stressful than your job? Also doesn't give any more Bronze Celebration Tokens, just xp and 5-10 Timewarped Badges. Apart from Spot the Difference for some reason, which did give Bronze Celebration Tokens - 5 of them, if memory serves.

OK...so this is what you do for Chapter 3
The Case of the Superstitious and Hungry Pirates

Pick up A Pirate Predicament from Alyx.
Talk to Bonenose in Tanaris ( /way 60.96, 44.96 )
Pick up Pirate Foods and Superstitions
Head to Booty Bay
Go to Old Port Authority Building (/way 42.54, 70.07 Entrance)
Talk to Kelsey Yance (way 42.86, 69.00 )
Go to the bunk building ( /way 42.28, 73.11 Entrance )
Pick up Property of Cooktolomew ( /way 42.86, 72.88 )
You'll receive Boonful Banquet
Talk to Scowling Rosa ( /way 41.74, 69.04 )

Done