The Way to His Heart...

For those confused as to why this quest isn't readily available is because there are prerequisites to complete first.

You need to start by talking to Orfus which starts a long quest chain and leads to Scalawag Point. Complete Street "Cred" then head over to the north ship in the same area and complete Swabbin' Soap. Once that is done, you have access to this daily quest.

Right, hands up everyone who felt guilty after reading the quest text! I certainly did :/

If anything, it only goes to show, that killing and looting isn't all fun and games, but that it has consequences too!

This - for some reason - took a bit to figure out. You need to collect fish, these fish are found in schools off the coast of the isle of spears in the southern region where you cross over to the isle w/ the Scalawag Point on it. These schools have a use icon over them so, go pick up 2 or 3 schools worth of fish.

Now that you have the fish, you have to be able to get a Bull to the Cow. To do this stand 20 yards from the bull on the isle with the scalawag point on it - and throw the bull a fish. Once you do this he will run at you. Back up 20 more yards and throw another fish, each time you throw one he'll run to the pt you were standing at, so continue to back up until you are able to stand on the isle of the spears and on a rock w/ a cow on it. The two should have hearts over their heads and you should get quest credit.